Email transactionnel : comparatif
Haraka vs KumoMTA
Prix, fonctionnalités documentées et limites issus de sources officielles datées, côte à côte. Les inconnues restent inconnues ; des unités de facturation différentes ne permettent pas de comparer directement les coûts.
Dernière vérification des sources : 10 nov. 2026
Pour quiHaraka is a Node.js SMTP server with a modular plugin architecture; the README says it handles thousands of concurrent connections and delivers thousands of messages per second.
Dernière vérification des sources : 9 nov. 2026
Pour quiKumoMTA is an open-source message transfer agent designed for high-performance outbound email, comparable to commercial enterprise MTAs such as Momentum, PowerMTA and Halon.
Ce que les sources établissent
Une lecture de la documentation officielle vérifiée pour Haraka et KumoMTA. Ce n’est ni un test pratique, ni un classement, ni la recommandation d’un produit.
- Questions d’achat traitées pour les deux
- 3 critères
- Documenté pour un seul
- 1 critère
- Non vérifié pour aucun
- 3 critères
- Prix
- Pas encore comparables
Prix
Haraka
Offre gratuite · prix payants non vérifiés ·
- Self-hosted: sans abonnement payant ·
KumoMTA
Offre gratuite · prix payants non vérifiés ·
- Self-hosted: sans abonnement payant ·
Aucune comparaison de prix complète à conditions égales n’est encore établie ; les prochaines étapes indiquent ce qui manque.
Questions d’achat traitées pour les deux
Même quand les libellés concordent, vérifiez dans chaque source les différences d’offres, d’unités et de périmètre.
- Volume d’envoi
- Haraka A default installation queues outbound mail to disk and delivers it to the appropriate MX for each recipient domain, retrying temporary failures automatically on the configured backoff schedule.
- KumoMTA Throughput depends on the hardware you deploy: for many millions of messages per hour the publisher advises the largest server you can, on bare metal or public or private cloud, with or without Kubernetes.
- IP dédiée
- Haraka By default the operating system’s routing table chooses the source IP; an operator can pin outbound mail to a specific IP per sender or domain by binding the address to a local interface or alias and setting mx.bind and mx.bind_helo in a get_mx plugin hook.
- KumoMTA By default mail leaves through the host's default interface; IPs can be grouped into pools, and a queue tied to a pool spreads its sends across the pool's IPs by weighted round robin. Separate IPs per mail stream are recommended to isolate reputation.
- Support
- Haraka The README lists GitHub Issues, a mailing list (implemented as a Haraka plugin) and a getting-started screencast as the ways to get help.
- KumoMTA Community support, plus paid Professional Services and Commercial Support from the KumoMTA team.
Limites à vérifier
- Haraka Haraka is not a mail store, a local delivery agent or an IMAP server and is designed to work alongside those systems.
- Haraka The documented default for outbound concurrency is 10,000 simultaneous deliveries per worker (concurrency_max); the effective total is that value multiplied by the number of nodes.
- KumoMTA KumoMTA is intended for experienced email operations professionals who are used to high-performance sending environments and familiar with DevOps practices.
- KumoMTA At least 4 CPU cores, 4 GB of RAM and 20 GB of storage. For high-performance systems the guide advises storage with the fastest IOPS and lowest latency, where local disk is much better than NAS or SAN; the same guidance applies to the Docker image.
Pas encore vérifié
Aucune source vérifiée pour l’un ou l’autre produit sur : domaines, conservation des journaux et frais de dépassement.
Documenté pour un seul produit, voir le tableau ci-dessous : KumoMTA : webhooks et événements.
« Non vérifié » signifie que nos sources vérifiées ne l’établissent pas. Cela ne veut pas dire qu’un produit n’a pas la fonctionnalité ni qu’il est gratuit.
Preuves côte à côte
Valeurs documentées avec leurs sources et dates de vérification ; les exigences que les sources n’établissent pas restent signalées.
- Documenté comme pris en charge
- Documenté comme non pris en charge
- Non vérifié Les sources ne l’établissent pas
- Sans objet
| Exigence | Haraka | KumoMTA |
|---|---|---|
| Tarifs | Offre gratuite · prix payants non vérifiés | Offre gratuite · prix payants non vérifiés |
| Pour qui | Haraka is a Node.js SMTP server with a modular plugin architecture; the README says it handles thousands of concurrent connections and delivers thousands of messages per second. Vérifié le 6 nov. 2026 · Haraka: haraka-project | KumoMTA is an open-source message transfer agent designed for high-performance outbound email, comparable to commercial enterprise MTAs such as Momentum, PowerMTA and Halon. Vérifié le 6 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-project |
| Limites de couverture | Haraka is not a mail store, a local delivery agent or an IMAP server and is designed to work alongside those systems. Vérifié le 6 nov. 2026 · Haraka: haraka-project
| KumoMTA is intended for experienced email operations professionals who are used to high-performance sending environments and familiar with DevOps practices. Vérifié le 6 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-project
|
| Volume d’envoi | A default installation queues outbound mail to disk and delivers it to the appropriate MX for each recipient domain, retrying temporary failures automatically on the configured backoff schedule. Dated publisher documentation (docs/Outbound.md) at release v3.4.0 (commit 2e1ea5b6) captured on 9 November 2026; supplier description, not a throughput or deliverability test. Mail is outbound only when a plugin marks it as relaying, for example after SMTP AUTH. Vérifié le 10 nov. 2026 · Haraka: haraka-outbound-project | Throughput depends on the hardware you deploy: for many millions of messages per hour the publisher advises the largest server you can, on bare metal or public or private cloud, with or without Kubernetes. Publisher hardware guide (docs/userguide/installation/hardware.md) at release 2026.09.29-b90d8bc1 (commit b90d8bc) captured 8 November 2026; supplier sizing guidance, not a measured throughput or performance test. Vérifié le 9 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-docs-hardware-project |
| Webhooks et événements | Non vérifié | Message events can be sent as webhooks to a user-defined HTTP endpoint, with queuing built in for durability if the receiving HTTP service has an error. Publisher documentation (docs/userguide/operation/webhooks.md) at release 2026.09.29-b90d8bc1 (commit b90d8bc) captured 8 November 2026. Webhooks are set up in the Lua policy script, with the log_hooks helper recommended. Supplier documentation, not a tested integration. Vérifié le 9 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-docs-webhooks-project |
| IP dédiée | By default the operating system’s routing table chooses the source IP; an operator can pin outbound mail to a specific IP per sender or domain by binding the address to a local interface or alias and setting mx.bind and mx.bind_helo in a get_mx plugin hook. Dated publisher documentation (docs/Outbound.md) at release v3.4.0 (commit 2e1ea5b6) captured on 9 November 2026; configuration guidance, not a deliverability test. The operator supplies and warms the IP addresses. Vérifié le 10 nov. 2026 · Haraka: haraka-outbound-project | By default mail leaves through the host's default interface; IPs can be grouped into pools, and a queue tied to a pool spreads its sends across the pool's IPs by weighted round robin. Separate IPs per mail stream are recommended to isolate reputation. Publisher documentation (docs/userguide/configuration/sendingips.md) at release 2026.09.29-b90d8bc1 (commit b90d8bc) captured 8 November 2026. The sending addresses are configured on the operator's own hosts. Supplier guidance, not a deliverability test. Vérifié le 9 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-docs-sendingips-project |
| Support | The README lists GitHub Issues, a mailing list (implemented as a Haraka plugin) and a getting-started screencast as the ways to get help. Dated publisher documentation at release v3.4.0 (commit 2e1ea5b6) captured on 9 November 2026; supplier description, not a deployment or independent test. These are community channels; response times and any paid support are not stated in the README. Vérifié le 10 nov. 2026 · Haraka: haraka-project | Community support, plus paid Professional Services and Commercial Support from the KumoMTA team. Publisher FAQ (docs/faq/how_can_i_get_help_with_kumomta.md) at release 2026.09.29-b90d8bc1 (commit b90d8bc) captured 8 November 2026. Paid support and services are arranged by contacting the KumoMTA team; the FAQ gives no prices or response times. Community support is described on the user guide's How To Get Help page. Vérifié le 9 nov. 2026 · KumoMTA: kumomta-docs-help-project |
| Note de couverture | Dated publisher project README captured on 5 November 2026; supplier description, not a deployment or independent test. Infrastructure, accounts, third-party services and managed offerings have separate costs and terms. | Dated publisher project README captured on 5 November 2026; supplier description, not a deployment or independent test. Infrastructure, accounts, third-party services and managed offerings have separate costs and terms. |
3 exigences sans preuve vérifiée ici
Non vérifié signifie que les sources examinées ne l’établissent pas ; cela ne veut pas dire que le produit en est dépourvu ni que c’est gratuit.
- Domaines Haraka: non vérifié · KumoMTA: non vérifié
- Conservation des journaux Haraka: non vérifié · KumoMTA: non vérifié
- Frais de dépassement Haraka: non vérifié · KumoMTA: non vérifié
Prochaines étapes
- Vérifiez les prix des offres payantes, la durée de facturation et les taxes de Haraka sur sa page de tarifs officielle ; seule son offre gratuite est vérifiée ici.
- Vérifiez les prix des offres payantes, la durée de facturation et les taxes de KumoMTA sur sa page de tarifs officielle ; seule son offre gratuite est vérifiée ici.
- Interrogez Haraka sur ces points : domaines, conservation des journaux et frais de dépassement. Nos sources ne les établissent pas encore.
- Interrogez KumoMTA sur ces points : domaines, conservation des journaux et frais de dépassement. Nos sources ne les établissent pas encore.
- HarakaVoir HarakaFiche et offres
- KumoMTAVoir KumoMTAFiche et offres
Les commissions ne modifient jamais les coûts, l’éligibilité ni l’ordre.