HR & payroll comparison
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools vs DutyDuke
Prices, documented capabilities and limits from dated official sources, side by side. Unknowns remain unknown; different billing units do not establish a cost winner.
Latest evidence check Nov 8, 2026
Who it is forFor UK PAYE: HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.
Latest evidence check Nov 9, 2026
Who it is forDutyDuke is an open-source HRIS for small and mid-sized companies to manage employees, absences, documents, equipment, benefits and more.
What the evidence answers
A reading of reviewed official documentation for HMRC Basic PAYE Tools and DutyDuke. It is not a hands-on test, a ranking or a recommendation of one product.
- Common buyer questions answered
- 2 requirements
- Documented for one
- 2 requirements
- Not verified for either
- 0 requirements
- Prices
- Not like-for-like yet
Price
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools
Free · paid prices not verified · · Market: GB
- no subscription charge · Market: GB ·
DutyDuke
Free plan · paid prices not verified ·
- Self-hosted: no subscription charge ·
A complete like-for-like price comparison is not established; the next steps say what is missing.
Common buyer questions answered
Even when labels match, check each source for differences in plans, units and scope.
- Payroll scope
- HMRC Basic PAYE Tools For UK PAYE: HMRC says the tool works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC.
- DutyDuke DutyDuke’s RBAC documentation lists salary and compensation data per employee (EMPLOYEE_EARNINGS) as a permission-controlled resource.
- Exports
- HMRC Basic PAYE Tools Payslips can be saved as PDF files and then emailed or printed; employees must agree before payslips are emailed.
- DutyDuke Employee profiles can be exported as PDF CVs, absence data has iCal export, and role permissions include a separate EXPORT action.
Limits to check
- HMRC Basic PAYE Tools For UK PAYE: HMRC says Basic PAYE Tools is not designed for agents or bookkeepers.
- DutyDuke The interface is available in English and Polish out of the box and is extensible through next-intl.
- DutyDuke A production install is self-managed: the deployment checklist asks for a unique JWT secret and field-encryption key, the production app URL, SMTP for real email delivery, a strong support password, PostgreSQL with the PostGIS extension and database backups.
Not verified yet
Every compared requirement has evidence for at least one.
Documented for one product only, shown in the table below: HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: country and employees.
Not verified means our reviewed sources do not establish it. It does not mean a product lacks the capability or that it costs nothing.
Side-by-side evidence
Documented values with their sources and check dates; requirements the sources do not establish stay marked.
- Documented as supported
- Documented as unsupported
- Not verified Sources do not establish it
- Not applicable
| Requirement | HMRC Basic PAYE Tools | DutyDuke |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | Free · paid prices not verified Market: GB | Free plan · paid prices not verified |
| Who it is for | For UK PAYE: HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov | DutyDuke is an open-source HRIS for small and mid-sized companies to manage employees, absences, documents, equipment, benefits and more. Verified Nov 7, 2026 · DutyDuke: dutyduke-project |
| Coverage limits | For UK PAYE: HMRC says Basic PAYE Tools is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov | The interface is available in English and Polish out of the box and is extensible through next-intl. Verified Nov 7, 2026 · DutyDuke: dutyduke-project
|
| Country | United Kingdom (GB) UK PAYE scope. GOV.UK guidance captured 3 November 2026: HMRC payroll software that sends payroll information to HMRC and requires HMRC employer registration and a PAYE Online login. No payroll run, filing or account test was performed. Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov | Not verified |
| Employees | 9 employees HMRC user guide captured 8 November 2026: up to 9 employees can be added; HMRC describes the software as for employers with fewer than 10 employees and not suitable for agents or bookkeepers. No payroll run was performed. Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-tools-how-to-use-20261108 | Not verified |
| Payroll scope | For UK PAYE: HMRC says the tool works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC. Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov | DutyDuke’s RBAC documentation lists salary and compensation data per employee (EMPLOYEE_EARNINGS) as a permission-controlled resource. Dated publisher RBAC documentation (docs/architecture/rbac.md) at release v0.0.1 (commit 56e43ab) captured 9 November 2026. Only the README, the deployment guide and this document were read; they do not describe payroll runs, tax calculation or payslips, but that does not prove the product lacks them. No payroll run was performed. Verified Nov 9, 2026 · DutyDuke: dutyduke-rbac-project |
| Exports | Payslips can be saved as PDF files and then emailed or printed; employees must agree before payslips are emailed. HMRC user guide captured 8 November 2026. No other export format is established here. No payroll run was performed. Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-tools-how-to-use-20261108 | Employee profiles can be exported as PDF CVs, absence data has iCal export, and role permissions include a separate EXPORT action. Dated publisher project README at release v0.0.1 (commit 56e43ab) captured 9 November 2026; supplier feature list, not a hands-on test. Other export formats are not stated. Verified Nov 9, 2026 · DutyDuke: dutyduke-project |
| Coverage note | UK PAYE scope only. Dated GOV.UK/HMRC guidance captured 3 November 2026; individual supplier pricing, terms and feature availability require confirmation. No payroll, tax calculation, account or test was performed. | Dated publisher project README captured on 7 November 2026; supplier description, not a deployment or independent test. Infrastructure, accounts, third-party services and managed offerings have separate costs and terms. |
Next steps
- Confirm HMRC Basic PAYE Tools's paid plan prices, billing term and taxes on its official pricing page; only its free plan is verified here.
- Confirm DutyDuke's paid plan prices, billing term and taxes on its official pricing page; only its free plan is verified here.
- Ask DutyDuke about country and employees; our sources do not establish them yet.
- HMRC Basic PAYE ToolsView HMRC Basic PAYE Tools pricingProfile and plans
- DutyDukeVisit DutyDukeProfile and plans
Commissions never change costs, eligibility or rankings.