HR & payroll comparison

HMRC Basic PAYE Tools vs PayCaptain UK Payroll

Prices, documented capabilities and limits from dated official sources, side by side. Unknowns remain unknown; different billing units do not establish a cost winner.

What the evidence answers

A reading of reviewed official documentation for HMRC Basic PAYE Tools and PayCaptain UK Payroll. It is not a hands-on test, a ranking or a recommendation of one product.

Common buyer questions answered
3 requirements
Documented for one
1 requirement
Not verified for either
0 requirements
Prices
Not like-for-like yet

Price

A complete like-for-like price comparison is not established; the next steps say what is missing.

Common buyer questions answered

Even when labels match, check each source for differences in plans, units and scope.

Country
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools United Kingdom (GB)
PayCaptain UK Payroll United Kingdom (GB)
Payroll scope
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools For UK PAYE: HMRC says the tool works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC.
PayCaptain UK Payroll PayCaptain says its monthly reports include the FPS and EPS submissions HMRC requires, and its annual reports include the final FPS, certified submissions to HMRC, P60s, P11Ds and, where required, gender pay gap reporting.
Exports
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools Payslips can be saved as PDF files and then emailed or printed; employees must agree before payslips are emailed.
PayCaptain UK Payroll The online payslips page says employees can access their payslip online through the secure platform, view past payslips, download PDFs and see a full breakdown of their pay.

Limits to check

  • HMRC Basic PAYE Tools For UK PAYE: HMRC says Basic PAYE Tools is not designed for agents or bookkeepers.
  • PayCaptain UK Payroll HMRC advises buyers to check whether the chosen payroll software has the features they need.

Not verified yet

Every compared requirement has evidence for at least one.

Documented for one product only, shown in the table below: HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: employees.

Not verified means our reviewed sources do not establish it. It does not mean a product lacks the capability or that it costs nothing.

Side-by-side evidence

Documented values with their sources and check dates; requirements the sources do not establish stay marked.

  • Documented as supported
  • Documented as unsupported
  • Not verified Sources do not establish it
  • Not applicable
Documented scope and limits; unverified dimensions remain unknown.
RequirementHMRC Basic PAYE ToolsPayCaptain UK Payroll
Pricing
Free · paid prices not verified

Market: GB

Quote only

Who it is for
For UK PAYE: HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.

Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov

HMRC lists PayCaptain from PayCaptain among recognised paid-for payroll software for online PAYE reporting.

Verified Nov 3, 2026 · PayCaptain UK Payroll: paycaptain-uk-payroll-gov

Coverage limits
For UK PAYE: HMRC says Basic PAYE Tools is not designed for agents or bookkeepers.

Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov

HMRC advises buyers to check whether the chosen payroll software has the features they need.

Verified Nov 3, 2026 · PayCaptain UK Payroll: paycaptain-uk-payroll-gov

Country
United Kingdom (GB)

UK PAYE scope. GOV.UK guidance captured 3 November 2026: HMRC payroll software that sends payroll information to HMRC and requires HMRC employer registration and a PAYE Online login. No payroll run, filing or account test was performed.

Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov

United Kingdom (GB)

PayCaptain home page (paycaptain.com) captured 9 November 2026; supplier marketing statement, not a payroll run or independent test. The page describes UK cloud payroll software for UK businesses and HMRC-approved payroll.

Verified Nov 10, 2026 · PayCaptain UK Payroll: paycaptain-uk-payroll-home-20261109b

Employees
9 employees

HMRC user guide captured 8 November 2026: up to 9 employees can be added; HMRC describes the software as for employers with fewer than 10 employees and not suitable for agents or bookkeepers. No payroll run was performed.

Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-tools-how-to-use-20261108

Not verified
Payroll scope
For UK PAYE: HMRC says the tool works out tax and National Insurance and sends payroll information to HMRC.

Verified Nov 3, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov

PayCaptain says its monthly reports include the FPS and EPS submissions HMRC requires, and its annual reports include the final FPS, certified submissions to HMRC, P60s, P11Ds and, where required, gender pay gap reporting.

PayCaptain payroll reports page captured 9 November 2026; supplier marketing statement, not a payroll run or independent test. Marketing description of reports; whether submissions are sent automatically and which tax rules are covered beyond these reports is not established.

Verified Nov 10, 2026 · PayCaptain UK Payroll: paycaptain-uk-payroll-reports-20261109b

Exports
Payslips can be saved as PDF files and then emailed or printed; employees must agree before payslips are emailed.

HMRC user guide captured 8 November 2026. No other export format is established here. No payroll run was performed.

Verified Nov 8, 2026 · HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-tools-how-to-use-20261108

The online payslips page says employees can access their payslip online through the secure platform, view past payslips, download PDFs and see a full breakdown of their pay.

PayCaptain online payslips page captured 9 November 2026; supplier marketing statement (an FAQ answer), not a payroll run or independent test. This is employee-side payslip access; employer exports, bulk payroll data, accounting exports and file formats are not stated; no export was performed.

Verified Nov 10, 2026 · PayCaptain UK Payroll: paycaptain-uk-payroll-payslips-20261109b

Coverage note

UK PAYE scope only. Dated GOV.UK/HMRC guidance captured 3 November 2026; individual supplier pricing, terms and feature availability require confirmation. No payroll, tax calculation, account or test was performed.

UK PAYE scope only. GOV.UK/HMRC guidance captured 3 November 2026; individual supplier pricing, terms and features require confirmation. No payroll, calculation, account or test was performed.

Next steps

  • Confirm HMRC Basic PAYE Tools's paid plan prices, billing term and taxes on its official pricing page; only its free plan is verified here.
  • Request a written quote from PayCaptain UK Payroll for your seats, usage and term.
  • Ask PayCaptain UK Payroll about employees; our sources do not establish it yet.

Commissions never change costs, eligibility or rankings.