HR & payroll 1 min read
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools vs BrightPay: UK payroll selection
Compare HMRC-documented UK PAYE scope, limitations and questions for a paid supplier.
On this page
A UK employer choosing payroll software
HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as free software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees. Its guidance says the tool can calculate employee tax and National Insurance and send payroll information to HMRC, but is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. An employer must register and have a PAYE Online login before using it.
HMRC separately lists BrightPay from Bright Software Group Ltd under paid-for software recognized for online PAYE reporting. The list is not an endorsement and does not establish BrightPay’s price, employee limits or feature coverage. Check the exact edition, tax year and current supplier terms before assuming a feature is included.
Practical comparison
For a small UK employer, establish whether the free tool covers required pay periods, payslips, pensions, access and reporting. For BrightPay, obtain current pricing, support, plan limits and migration details for the same workflow. Do not assume a paid listing implies any particular feature or that either option meets your legal obligations automatically.
If changing systems, check employee payroll IDs, historical data, filing and backup arrangements against current official guidance and the supplier’s instructions. This comparison did not create an account, run payroll, submit information or test either application.
Scope
This page describes UK PAYE software selection, not tax, pension, accounting or legal advice. HMRC’s recognition and source listings can change, and neither is a guarantee of product performance or compliance for an individual employer.
Sources
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov · Evidence: documentation · Not checked
BrightPay UK Payroll: recognized-payroll-gov · Evidence: documentation · Not checked
Next step
Tools in this guide
BrightPay UK Payroll
HR & payroll
Covered in this guide
For UK PAYE: HMRC lists BrightPay from Bright Software Group Ltd among recognized paid-for payroll software for PAYE reporting.
PricingOn the vendor siteHMRC Basic PAYE Tools
HR & payroll
Covered in this guide
For UK PAYE: HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.
PricingFree plan availableMarket: GBPrice terms
Free · paid prices not verified · Market: GB
PayCaptain UK Payroll
HR & payroll
HMRC lists PayCaptain from PayCaptain among recognised paid-for payroll software for online PAYE reporting.
PricingCustom quotePrice terms
Quote only
Moneysoft Payroll Manager
HR & payroll
HMRC lists Payroll Manager from Moneysoft Limited among recognised paid-for payroll software for online PAYE reporting.
PricingOn the vendor site
VendorClue research
Read the evidence behind software costs
Choose the research you want about software costs and plan limits, then confirm your address by email. We write only about the topics you select.
Keep reading
All guidesWordPress hosting
A monthly hosting rate can mean four years of upfront payment
A dated Hostinger prepayment example and a checklist for checking the current renewal terms.
WordPress hosting
WordPress hosting: compare the first payment and renewal
A historical hosting-price example and a checklist for comparing current upfront and renewal costs.
Transactional email
Email history, event delivery and archiving: compare the scope
Compare the retained evidence for Resend, Postmark and Amazon SES without treating activity history, statistics and archiving as the same service.