HR & payroll 1 min read
Collegia FreePayroll vs Basic PAYE Tools: UK payroll checks
Compare HMRC listing scope, known Basic PAYE Tools limits and selection checks for UK employers.
Product data changed. The editorial conclusion needs review. Verified catalogue facts changed; review dependent conclusions.
On this page
What the HMRC listings establish
HMRC lists FreePayroll from Collegia Partners Limited in its free payroll software section for businesses with fewer than ten employees. HMRC Basic PAYE Tools is its own free payroll software for the same broad employer-size group. Check the current tax-year version and each provider’s detailed terms before choosing.
The government list concerns online PAYE reporting and does not recommend one product over another. It does not establish identical features, support or costs for every employer.
Payroll work and the people who perform it
HMRC says Basic PAYE Tools can work out tax and National Insurance for employees and send payroll information to HMRC. It also says the tool is not designed for agents or bookkeepers. These statements describe Basic PAYE Tools; the selected HMRC listing does not establish the equivalent workflow or agent support for FreePayroll.
Ask the supplier how its product handles pay frequencies, payslips, pensions and reporting for the employer and tax year in question. Confirm the roles, access and support arrangements before migrating payroll data.
Limits, costs and evidence
HMRC places FreePayroll in a free-software section for businesses with fewer than ten employees, but the reviewed listing does not describe every licensing condition, optional charge or service level. Obtain the supplier’s current conditions and compare them with the tasks you need to perform.
Check how employee identifiers, year-to-date figures and prior records are transferred, and who will verify the first run. This comparison uses dated government documentation; no account, payroll calculation, submission or payment was performed. It is not a compliance guarantee or a substitute for professional advice.
Sources
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools: basic-paye-gov · Evidence: documentation · Not checked
Collegia FreePayroll: collegia-freepayroll-gov · Evidence: documentation · Not checked
Next step
Tools in this guide
Collegia FreePayroll
HR & payroll
Covered in this guide
For UK PAYE, HMRC lists FreePayroll from Collegia Partners Limited as recognised payroll software for online reporting.
Documented price£10/moPrice terms
Documented price: £10/mo · Plan: Pro · billed annually · commitment not established
HMRC Basic PAYE Tools
HR & payroll
Covered in this guide
For UK PAYE: HMRC describes Basic PAYE Tools as payroll software for businesses with fewer than 10 employees.
PricingFree plan availableMarket: GBPrice terms
Free · paid prices not verified · Market: GB
BrightPay UK Payroll
HR & payroll
For UK PAYE: HMRC lists BrightPay from Bright Software Group Ltd among recognized paid-for payroll software for PAYE reporting.
PricingOn the vendor sitePayCaptain UK Payroll
HR & payroll
HMRC lists PayCaptain from PayCaptain among recognised paid-for payroll software for online PAYE reporting.
PricingCustom quotePrice terms
Quote only
VendorClue research
Read the evidence behind software costs
Choose the research you want about software costs and plan limits, then confirm your address by email. We write only about the topics you select.
Keep reading
All guidesWordPress hosting
A monthly hosting rate can mean four years of upfront payment
A dated Hostinger prepayment example and a checklist for checking the current renewal terms.
WordPress hosting
WordPress hosting: compare the first payment and renewal
A historical hosting-price example and a checklist for comparing current upfront and renewal costs.
Transactional email
Email history, event delivery and archiving: compare the scope
Compare the retained evidence for Resend, Postmark and Amazon SES without treating activity history, statistics and archiving as the same service.