Accounting 2 min read

hledger vs kivitendo: plain text books or a German-market ERP

Plain text double-entry accounting with no stated country scope, against a web ERP built for the German market with offers, invoices and stock.

Country scope decides first

kivitendo is the only one of the two with an explicit country scope: it is a web-based ERP system for the German market, developed for German-speaking users, with an English interface also available. Its README does not name specific German tax or reporting rules. hledger documents no country, chart of accounts or tax regime.

If you need ERP workflows for the German market, kivitendo was built in that context; confirm the tax and bookkeeping functions you rely on in its German documentation. If you work elsewhere, or want books that follow no particular jurisdiction's defaults, hledger supports your preferred account names, currencies and number formats and leaves the structure to you.

Ledger or operations

hledger is double-entry accounting software that keeps money, investments, invoices, time and inventory in plain text files, with reports such as balance sheets and income statements. kivitendo is an operations system: articles, goods, customers, suppliers, stock, offers, invoices and collection, plus booking preparation for financial accounting and basic CRM.

hledger's README calls its interfaces basic, while kivitendo is a web application. A team that handles goods and offers in a browser is looking for something different from a bookkeeper comfortable with text files and version control.

Licences and running them

hledger is free software under the GNU General Public License v3.0 or later and installs on Unix, Mac or Windows. kivitendo ships the GNU General Public License text in doc/COPYING rather than at the repository root, and its installation and configuration documentation is only available in German, with an Ansible playbook for Ubuntu.

hledger's README capture is a tagged release; kivitendo had no GitHub releases, so its README was first captured from a master branch that was receiving commits on the capture day and later from its release-4.1.0 tag. Nothing was installed or tested for this comparison, and hosting and support terms are outside the captured sources. kivitendo’s scope page, whose footer shows 2017, calls the program sources free and says the terms of the GPL 2 apply, as is and without warranty; it states no price for hosting or support.

Sources

hledger: hledger-project · Evidence: documentation · Not checked

kivitendo: kivitendo-project · Evidence: documentation · Not checked

Next step

Tools in this guide

All accounting tools
All guides