Project management 1 min read

Trac vs Phorge: self-hosted tools for software teams

A minimal wiki and issue tracker beside Git or Subversion, or a broader suite with code review and repository hosting. Scope and licences.

Product data changed. The editorial conclusion needs review. Verified catalogue facts changed; review dependent conclusions.

Built for software projects

Both products target software development rather than general team planning. Trac describes itself as a minimalistic web-based software project management and bug/issue tracking system, with an interface to Git and Subversion, an integrated wiki, issue tracking and reports. Phorge describes a collection of web applications for software companies, covering code review and auditing, repository hosting and browsing, bug tracking, project management and conversations with team members.

The difference is breadth. Trac connects to Git or Subversion repositories and adds a wiki, tickets and reports around them. Phorge can host and browse the repositories itself and adds code review and team conversation, so it can take over more of a team's tooling, and there is more of it to run.

Licences and stewardship

Trac is distributed under the modified BSD License; Phorge is released under Apache 2.0 except where otherwise noted. Both are permissive licences. Phorge is a community-maintained fork of Phabricator developed by the Phorge Team, while Trac's README is signed by the Trac Team and its licence file names Edgewall Software.

What the READMEs leave out

Neither README lists system requirements. Trac points to INSTALL.rst and UPGRADE.rst, and Phorge's README has no installation section at all. Both GitHub repositories are mirrors of projects developed elsewhere and neither publishes GitHub releases, so both captures come from the default branch.

Neither product was installed or tested for this comparison, and neither README documents a hosted offering or price.

Sources

Trac: trac-project · Evidence: documentation · Not checked

Phorge: phorge-project · Evidence: documentation · Not checked

Next step

Tools in this guide

All project management tools
All guides